Magical Make an Offer vs Pay What You Want

Magical Make an Offer logo Magical Make an Offer vs Pay What You Want logo Pay What You Want

How Magical Make an Offer and Pay What You Want compare on the Shopify App Store: rating, review count, pricing, the Built for Shopify badge, and where each one ranks in the store's organic search results. Every number is the App Store's own and is never edited.

Updated October 23, 2026 · App Store data

Maintained by Rankbase, built by a Shopify app developer

Magical Make an Offer vs Pay What You Want at a glance

As of October 23, 2026, Magical Make an Offer is rated 4.7 stars from 170 reviews and Pay What You Want is rated 4.6 stars from 54 reviews on the Shopify App Store.

  • Rating: Magical Make an Offer has the higher rating, 4.7 stars against 4.6.
  • Reviews: Magical Make an Offer has more reviews, 170 against 54.
  • Pricing: Magical Make an Offer lists "Free to install", Pay What You Want "Free plan available".
  • Built for Shopify: Both carry the Built for Shopify badge.
Magical Make an Offer and Pay What You Want on the Shopify App Store, as of October 23, 2026: rating, review count, pricing label, the Built for Shopify badge, and the date each app's data was last read from the store.
Fact Magical Make an Offer Pay What You Want
Tagline Best Offer App • Bargain, Negotiate + Pay What You Want Offer easy donation & make an offer with better price bargain
Rating ★ 4.7 ★ 4.6
Reviews 170 54
Pricing Free to install Free plan available
Built for Shopify Built for Shopify Built for Shopify
Data as of October 23, 2026 October 23, 2026

Ratings, review counts, pricing labels and badges are read from each app's Shopify App Store search result card. Rankings are the store's organic results for the searches Rankbase tracks; sponsored results are excluded.

Where each app ranks in App Store search

Every Shopify App Store search Rankbase tracks where Magical Make an Offer or Pay What You Want is in the top 10 today, with the position merchants see. Organic results only, across 3,809 tracked searches; sponsored placements never count.
App Store search Magical Make an Offer Pay What You Want
Both apps rank · 2 searches
Pay What You Want #2 #1
Make An Offer #2 #5
Only Magical Make an Offer ranks · 10 searches
Magical #2 not in top 10
Amaka #4 not in top 10
Magical Fees #4 not in top 10
Magic #5 not in top 10
Offer #5 not in top 10
Logo Maker #6 not in top 10
Plytix #6 not in top 10
Drop Magic #8 not in top 10
Magic Bundle #9 not in top 10
Offers #10 not in top 10
Only Pay What You Want ranks · 15 searches
Tpay not in top 10 #4
Xpay not in top 10 #4
After Pay not in top 10 #6
Phone Pay not in top 10 #6
Yozo not in top 10 #6
Pay U not in top 10 #7
Razor Pay not in top 10 #7
Yanet not in top 10 #7
Easy Pay not in top 10 #8
Whatomation not in top 10 #8
Payu not in top 10 #9
Print4you not in top 10 #9
Whapi not in top 10 #9
Payfy not in top 10 #10
Wati not in top 10 #10

In the App Store's organic search results, Magical Make an Offer ranks in the top 10 for 12 of the 3,809 searches we track and Pay What You Want for 17. They share 2 searches and split them evenly: each ranks higher on 1.

Frequently asked questions

Is Magical Make an Offer or Pay What You Want rated higher on the Shopify App Store?

Magical Make an Offer has the higher rating, 4.7 stars against 4.6. Magical Make an Offer has more reviews, 170 against 54.

Which has more reviews, Magical Make an Offer or Pay What You Want?

Magical Make an Offer has more reviews, 170 against 54.

Which ranks higher in Shopify App Store search, Magical Make an Offer or Pay What You Want?

In the App Store's organic search results, Magical Make an Offer ranks in the top 10 for 12 of the 3,809 searches we track and Pay What You Want for 17. They share 2 searches and split them evenly: each ranks higher on 1.

How is this comparison made?

Rankbase records the organic results merchants see when they search the Shopify App Store for 3,809 popular keywords, refreshed daily for published rankings and at least weekly for the rest. Each app's rating, review count, pricing label and Built for Shopify badge are taken from its App Store search result card, so they are exactly what merchants see; the date next to each app is the last time it appeared in any tracked top 10. Sponsored results are excluded, and nothing on this page is edited by hand, including for Rankbase's own apps.

More comparisons

Magical Make an Offer against other apps

Pay What You Want against other apps

Rankbase paired these two apps on September 8, 2026, when both ranked in the top 3 for "pay what you want". The page stays as long as either app keeps ranking or the comparison keeps being read, and every number on it is refreshed from the App Store.

All app comparisons →   ·   Browse keyword rankings →

Rank higher on the Shopify App Store

Rankbase helps Shopify app developers track keyword positions, analyze install click data, and optimize app listings to rank higher in the Shopify App Store.

Explore Rankbase →

Built by Craftshift

Rankbase is made by Craftshift, a Shopify Partner building apps for product images, variants, and bulk catalog work. We built Rankbase to track the App Store rankings of our own apps first, then opened it to other developers, and this directory grew out of that work. The rankings on these pages are Shopify's own organic search results; we never edit them, including for our own apps.

Craftshift apps on the Shopify App Store