The 10 Best Insurance Apps for Shopify

The top 10 apps merchants see when they search the Shopify App Store for insurance, in the exact order the store ranks them. Only Shopify's organic ranking is shown, never sponsored ads.

Updated September 8, 2026 · Organic ranking

Maintained by Rankbase, built by a Shopify app developer

Search this word in the App Store and what comes back is shipping protection rather than insurance products, and the vendors are usually the first to say so. Most of the leading listings state outright that they are not an insurer and do not underwrite anything. What they sell is the widget that offers an optional fee at the cart and the portal for handling claims afterwards. The fee stays with you, and so does the cost when a parcel goes missing.

Mechanically the fee is an ordinary line item, a product variant added to the cart or during checkout, because Shopify has no separate cart-level charge to hang it on. That detail is worth carrying, because adding a line during checkout is refused outright when the shopper is paying by an accelerated method, which is one reason most of these put the toggle in the cart instead.

1

Insureful Shipping Protection

★ 4.8 (73 reviews) · Free plan available

Turn Shipping Protection into Profit Center Keep, 100% of Fees
Built for Shopify
2

Captain Shipping Protection

★ 4.9 (307 reviews) · Free trial available

Shipping protection/shipping insurance fully controlled by you
Built for Shopify
3

Shipping Protection —Shipcheck

★ 5.0 (93 reviews) · Free plan available

Shipping insurance—Package protection as cart, checkout upsell
Built for Shopify
4

Navidium Shipping Protection

★ 4.8 (391 reviews) · Free to install

Shipping protection/shipping insurance fee as a cart upsell
Built for Shopify
5

Sam Shipping Protection Upsell

★ 4.9 (100 reviews) · Free plan available

Shipping protection/shipping insurance fully controlled by you
Built for Shopify
6

XCOTTON Post Purchase Guard

★ 5.0 (609 reviews) · Free

Solutions of shipping protection, return and extended warranty
7

ShipGuard: Shipping Protection

★ 4.3 (20 reviews) · Free to install

Custom shipping protection/shipping insurance managed by you.
Built for Shopify
8

SureBright Product Protection

★ 4.8 (53 reviews) · Free to install

Earn profits with a complete warranty and shipping solution
9

Shipping Protection ‑Insurance

★ 5.0 (2 reviews) · Free

Boost your revenue with shipping protection & Insurance
10

Protectify Shipping Protection

★ 5.0 (7 reviews) · Free to install

Protect your orders from loss, damage, and improve revenue
Built for Shopify

Compare the top 3 head-to-head

All app comparisons →

What to look for in a Insurance app

Find out who actually pays a claim: The common arrangement is that you keep the fee and you settle the claims, with the app providing the workflow. That is a reasonable trade if you have the volume to average it out and a bad one if you do not. Where a listing uses the word insurance about itself without naming an underwriter, treat that as the first question rather than a detail, and whether such an arrangement needs a licence where you trade is a question for someone qualified, not for an app listing.
Where the offer appears: A toggle on the cart page reaches everyone. One injected during checkout does not, because accelerated payment methods block the change that adds it. If a sizeable share of your orders come through wallets, that difference decides how much of this you will ever sell.
How it lands on the order: Because the fee is a line item, it travels with the order into your reporting, your tax treatment and any refund. Ask what a partial refund does to it, and how it is labelled where customers and your accountant will both see it.

Frequently asked questions

Which is the best Insurance app for Shopify?

Based on the Shopify App Store's own organic ranking for "insurance", Insureful Shipping Protection currently holds the #1 spot, with a 4.8 star rating across 73 reviews. The best choice for your store still depends on your requirements, so compare the top results above.

How is this ranking determined?

We record the organic results merchants actually see when searching the Shopify App Store for "insurance", refreshed daily. Shopify's own sponsored ("Ad") results are excluded, so positions reflect its real search ranking rather than paid promotion. Source: the Shopify App Store search results for "insurance", you can verify the current ranking there yourself.

Which Insurance apps are Built for Shopify?

7 of the top 10 insurance apps hold the Built for Shopify badge: Insureful Shipping Protection, Captain Shipping Protection, Shipping Protection —Shipcheck, Navidium Shipping Protection, Sam Shipping Protection Upsell and more.

What does the Built for Shopify badge mean?

Built for Shopify
Built for Shopify is the highest level of recognition Shopify awards an app. To earn the badge, an app must meet Shopify's standards for safety, performance, ease of use, and proven usefulness: it cannot slow down the admin, storefront, or checkout, must integrate seamlessly into the Shopify admin, and must demonstrate quality through installs, reviews, and ratings over time. When comparing similar apps, preferring ones with the badge is a safe default. Learn more about the Built for Shopify badge →

As of September 8, 2026, the top-ranked insurance app on the Shopify App Store is Insureful Shipping Protection, with a 4.8 star rating across 73 reviews. 7 of the top 10 carry the Built for Shopify badge, and the average rating is 4.9 stars across 1,655 reviews.

Related keyword rankings

All Insurance rankings → · Browse all keywords →

Rank higher on the Shopify App Store

Rankbase helps Shopify app developers track keyword positions, analyze install click data, and optimize app listings to rank higher in the Shopify App Store.

Explore Rankbase →

Built by Craftshift

Rankbase is made by Craftshift, a Shopify Partner building apps for product images, variants, and bulk catalog work. We built Rankbase to track the App Store rankings of our own apps first, then opened it to other developers, and this directory grew out of that work. The rankings on these pages are Shopify's own organic search results; we never edit them, including for our own apps.

Craftshift apps on the Shopify App Store